Framework/Not yet filed
The structure of the claim.
A class action is not an accusation; it is a set of propositions a court can test. What follows is the architecture of the proposed claim — who would be sued, in what forum, on what grounds, and by what route the case would reach a hearing.
The shape of the proceeding.
- Proposed defendant
- The Crown in right of Canada
- Proposed forum
- Federal Court of Canada
- Representative plaintiff
- To be appointed on certification
- Class
- Residents of Canada within the defined class period
- Status
- Framework published · statement of claim not issued
Each ground, stated with its elements.
A ground that cannot be broken into elements cannot be argued. Each of the four below is set out with the questions a court would ask, in the order it would ask them.
01
Breach of Fiduciary Duty
- 01Duty
- 02Breach
- 03Loss
In taking custody of the national scientific record, the Crown placed itself in a position of trust over information Canadians cannot obtain for themselves. A fiduciary may not use that position for its own purposes. Where evidence was held by the state and kept from the people it described, the duty of loyalty is engaged.
02
Misfeasance in Public Office
- 01Authority
- 02Knowledge
- 03Unlawful act
- 04Harm
This tort does not require a statute to be broken. It requires a public officer to exercise lawful authority unlawfully, either knowing the harm that would follow, or with reckless indifference to it. The framework treats the question as evidentiary: who knew, when, and what did they do next.
03
Suppression & Non-Disclosure
- 01Known
- 02Held
- 03Withheld
The central factual question is narrow and answerable. What did the Crown know, at what date did it know it, and what was done with the knowledge once it was in hand? A record that exists and is not disclosed is a different matter from a record that never existed.
04
Negligent Misrepresentation
- 01Duty of care
- 02Untrue statement
- 03Reliance
- 04Detriment
Where a regulator issues statements of settled certainty while the underlying record supports doubt, a duty of care is owed to the people who relied on that statement and arranged their lives, their treatment and their families around it.
Five questions the Court asks before the class exists.
Certification is a procedural gate, not a trial of the merits. Passing it requires evidence that the questions are common — which is why the evidence protocol is organised around common issues rather than individual grievances.
01
Cause of action
The pleadings must disclose a reasonable cause of action on the facts as pleaded.
02
Identifiable class
Two or more persons, defined by objective criteria, capable of being ascertained.
03
Common issues
Questions of fact or law common to the class, answerable in a single proceeding.
04
Preferable procedure
A class proceeding must be fairer and more efficient than alternatives.
05
Representative plaintiff
A suitable representative, without a conflict of interest, able to fund the proceeding.
What the claim would ask for.
A declaration
That the Crown held the scientific record in trust for the public, and that the trust was breached.
Aggregate damages
Assessed on a class-wide basis, with individual issues reserved where loss must be proved.
Disclosure
An order for production and publication of the records identified in the evidence ledger.
Corrective notice
Publication of the record, so that the correction reaches the people the original statement reached.
Costs
Costs of the proceeding, and such further relief as the Court considers just.
Standing note
This site publishes a working framework for a proposed class action against the Crown in right of Canada. No claim has been filed, no court has certified any class, and no finding of fact or liability has been made by any court or regulator. Nothing on this site is legal advice. Every exhibit described is subject to independent source verification before it is relied upon. If you believe you have suffered a loss, consult a lawyer licensed in your province or territory; time limits apply.